See all 67 photos

Listed by: Houlihan Lawrence Inc.

$3,895,000

Est. payment - /mo

Save Virtual Tour

5 Beds

5 Baths

6,242 SqFt

New

1174 Potter Mountain RD Gilboa, NY 12076

Save Virtual Tour

REQUEST A TOUR If you would like to see this home without being there in person, select the "Virtual Tour" option and your agent will contact you to discuss available opportunities.

In-PersonVirtual Tour

Mon

Jun

Tue

Jun

Wed

Jun

UPDATED:

Key Details

Property Type Single Family Home

Sub Type Single Family Residence

Listing Status Active

Purchase Type For Sale

Square Footage 6,242 sqft

Price per Sqft $623

MLS Listing ID 20252165

Style Greek Revival

Bedrooms 5

Full Baths 4

Year Built 1837

Annual Tax Amount $8,180

Tax Year 8180

Lot Size 37.000 Acres

Acres 37.0

Property Sub-Type Single Family Residence

Source Hudson Valley Catskills Region Multiple List Service (Ulster County Board of REALTORS®)

Property Description

Welcome to Potter Mountain House, a masterfully reimagined Greek Revival church turned luxury designer estate. The original timber-framed structure was constructed in 1837 as the Manorkill Methodist Church, serving its community for over a century before being carefully dismantled and relocated to its current site in Gilboa, NY. Now sited on 37 acres with sweeping Catskill Mountain views, the building began its two-year transformation in 2023 by the boutique design/build firm ICDT Studio into a breathtaking 6,242-square-foot residence—honoring its historic soul while layering in a refined, design-forward sensibility. The result is a one-of-a-kind architectural offering that balances reverence for the past with an intentional, contemporary design ethos.

Inside, every detail delivers. The three finished levels are anchored by a soaring Great Room featuring the restored original timber frame, hand-hewn beams, and a full wall of windows that frame the panoramic mountain views. A round, sculptural gas fireplace adds warmth and ambiance between the living and dining spaces, while the chef's kitchen features a 48'' AGA induction range, Fisher & Paykel appliances, Waterworks fixtures, and a stunning stone-clad island. A walk-in pantry accented by reclaimed wood beams and lined with Zellige tile completes the space. The spacious, open layout provides a striking balance of style and function for both daily living and entertaining.

Ascending a symmetrical dual staircase, the Great Room opens into a dramatic library loft housed within the home's original church cupola, crowned by an 18-foot long, multi-point glass chandelier and custom floor-to-ceiling bookcases. Just off the dining area, a glass-fronted, 625-bottle refrigerated wine room is enclosed by custom arched iron doors. The home offers five bedrooms and four-and-a-half exquisitely finished baths, each appointed with radiant heat, curated tilework, and an artful mix of stone and marble. The secluded primary suite occupies its own private wing and includes a spa-like bath with soaking tub, dual showers, Bardiglio marble, and double vanities framed by custom glass partitions. The walkout lower level features a secondary living room with wet bar, two guest quarters, built-in bunk room, and a spacious laundry suite with double washers and dryers. Lime-washed walls, wide-plank white oak flooring, and bespoke lighting carry a sense of quiet luxury throughout.

Outside, multiple entertaining terraces and an expansive rear deck take full advantage of the natural surroundings, while a stream and seasonal waterfalls enhance the sense of tranquility. Additional features include an attached, heated, two-car garage, all-purpose mudroom, and a backyard master plan already prepared with plans for a future pool. Just 20 minutes from Windham Mountain Club, under an hour to Hudson and Albany, and a little over two hours from NYC, Potter Mountain House offers sanctuary, scale, and elevated design. A fully furnished option is also available, providing a true turnkey experience for effortless move-in. Unlike anything else on the market—distinctive, historic, and telling a story entirely its own.

Location

State NY

County Schoharie

Area Conesville

Zoning RES1

Interior

Interior Features Beamed Ceilings, Bookcases, Cathedral Ceiling(s), Ceiling Fan(s), Chandelier, Entrance Foyer, High Ceilings, High Speed Internet, Kitchen Island, Natural Woodwork, Open Floorplan, Pantry, Smart Thermostat, Soaking Tub, Stone Counters, Storage, Walk-In Closet(s), Wet Bar

Heating Central, Forced Air, Heat Pump, Propane, Radiant Floor

Cooling Ceiling Fan(s), Central Air, Heat Pump

Flooring Engineered Hardwood, Tile

Fireplaces Number 1

Fireplaces Type Gas, Great Room

Fireplace Yes

Laundry Laundry Room, Lower Level

Exterior

Exterior Feature Garden, Lighting, Private Yard

Garage Spaces 2.0

Garage Description 2.0

Utilities Available Cable Connected, Electricity Connected, Propane, Underground Utilities

View Meadow, Mountain(s), Panoramic, Trees/Woods

Roof Type Metal

Porch Deck, Patio

Total Parking Spaces 2

Garage Yes

Building

Lot Description Back Yard, Gentle Sloping, Landscaped, Meadow, Private, Sloped, Views, Wooded

Story 3

Foundation Concrete Perimeter, Slab, Stone

Sewer Engineered Septic

Water Private, Well

Architectural Style Greek Revival

Level or Stories Tri-Level

Schools

High Schools Gilboa

School District Gilboa

Others

Tax ID 204.-3-7.3

Virtual Tour https://www.zillow.com/view-imx/20e66395-ed9c-4d91-bf9a-f36d4fb6a266/?utm_source=captureapp

GET MORE INFORMATION

Jonathan Greene

Team Leader | License ID: 1433604

+1(973) 873-0734

QUICK SEARCH